Invoice Matching Explained: 2-Way, 3-Way and 4-Way Matching

Invoice matching serves as the backbone of effective procurement and accounting systems. At its core, it involves detailed verification of purchase orders, supplier invoices, and goods received notes, ensuring perfect alignment between what a company orders, receives, and pays for. This alignment is important for preventing over-payments, detecting fraud, and safeguarding against financial discrepancies.

What Is Invoice Matching?

Invoice matching is a process in finance and procurement, involving the meticulous comparison and reconciliation of three key documents: purchase orders (POs), supplier invoices, and goods received notes (GRNs). This process is integral to ensuring the alignment of information across these documents.

Acting as an essential control mechanism, invoice matching ensures that payments are made only for legitimate and authorized purchases, and that these payments accurately correspond to the correct quantities and prices. Its primary function is to safeguard against payment errors, discrepancies, and fraudulent activities, while also aiding in maintaining precise financial records. This, in turn, enhances the efficiency of the accounts payable process.

However, invoice matching has several challenges, particularly due to many companies’ reliance on manual processes. These manual processes are not only labor-intensive but also susceptible to errors and inefficiencies.

A notable challenge is the occurrence of data inconsistencies among purchase orders, receipt records, and supplier invoices. This often leads to processing and payment delays. Additionally, discrepancies or errors can lead to invoice exceptions, causing further hold-ups and necessitating extra effort for resolution. Collectively, these challenges significantly affect the efficiency and effectiveness of the invoice matching process.

The Invoice Matching Process

The invoice matching process may vary slightly depending on a company’s specific procedures and software. However, the common steps involved in invoice matching, to ensure financial accuracy and prevent discrepancies, are as follows:

Step-by-Step Overview of the Invoice Matching Process

  1. Receipt of Invoice: The process begins with the accounts payable department receiving an invoice from a supplier. This invoice details the goods or services provided and their associated costs.
  2. Purchase Order Verification: The received invoice is then compared against the relevant purchase order (PO). The PO is the original document issued by the company to order the goods or services, containing details such as quantities, prices, and descriptions.
  3. Goods Received Note Comparison: Alongside the PO, the invoice is matched with the goods received note (GRN). The GRN is a record confirming the receipt of goods or services as per the PO, ensuring the invoice corresponds to the actual delivery.
  4. Additional Checks: In more comprehensive matching processes, like 4-way matching, an additional step involves comparing the invoice against an inspection report or quality check document, crucial in industries where specific standards are mandatory.
  5. Resolving Discrepancies: If discrepancies are found between the invoice, PO, and GRN, these must be resolved before proceeding, which may involve contacting the supplier for clarification or correcting internal records.
  6. Approval for Payment: Once a match is confirmed and all details are verified, the invoice is approved for payment. This indicates that the goods or services were received as per the order, and the prices charged are correct.

Why Is Invoice Matching Important?

Invoice matching is a cornerstone of effective financial management for businesses of all sizes and industries. It aligns a company’s financial records with actual expenses, also playing a role in strategic decision-making.

Here’s why invoice matching is important:

  • Financial Integrity: It ensures that payments align with actual goods or services received. By comparing invoices, purchase orders, and receipt notes, it prevents overpayments or payments for undelivered items.
  • Error Detection and Fraud Prevention: Invoice matching process is instrumental in identifying pricing and quantity discrepancies, data entry errors, or possible fraudulent activities, enabling AP teams to address these issues promptly.
  • Accurate Record Keeping: As a vital part of bookkeeping, invoice matching ensures expenses are accurately reflected in financial statements, aiding in profitability analysis, budgeting, and forecasting.
  • Efficient Payment Processing: Matching invoices with corresponding purchase orders and receipts streamlines payments, preventing duplicates and fostering timely payments to maintain positive vendor relationships.
  • Regulatory Compliance and Auditing: The process creates a clear audit trail, essential for internal audits and compliance with financial regulations, ensuring all transactions are legitimate and authorized.
  • Budget Management: It allows for precise tracking of expenditures against budgets, aiding in better financial control.
  • Improved Vendor Relationships: Efficient invoice matching contributes to healthy, trust-based relationships with suppliers through timely and accurate payments.
  • Operational Efficiency: Automation in invoice matching can significantly reduce manual efforts and errors in large and medium systems, increasing efficiency and leading to cost savings.
  • Data-Driven Insights: The data generated through invoice matching is invaluable for analytics, helping in spending pattern analysis, supplier negotiations, and informed procurement decisions.

Different Types of Invoice Matching

There are several types of invoice matching, each suited to different business needs and complexities. Smaller businesses with lower volumes of transactions may find 2-way matching sufficient and more cost-effective, whereas larger businesses with higher transaction volumes might require more rigorous methods like 3-way or 4-way matching to manage their complex financial processes effectively.

2-way matching

2-way matching represents the simplest form of invoice matching. In this process, the system compares the supplier’s invoice directly with the purchase order (PO). The primary objective is to verify that both documents contain the same information, including quantities, prices, and other pertinent details. It focuses on matching critical information like item descriptions, prices, and quantities ordered with those billed on the invoice.

If the comparison reveals no discrepancies or errors between the PO and the invoice, the invoice is deemed ready for payment approval. This type of matching is especially suitable for businesses with straightforward transactions and a limited number of suppliers. It offers a quick and efficient way to validate transactions without the need for extensive paperwork or verification steps.

2-way matching is particularly beneficial in smaller operations where procurement processes are less complex, and the risk of significant discrepancies is lower. However, it’s important to note that while 2-way matching is efficient, it might not provide sufficient control for larger businesses or for transactions where delivery and quality verification are critical.

3-way matching

Three-way matching adds an extra layer of verification to the invoice matching process, enhancing control over the company’s expenses. This method involves comparing three key documents: a purchase order (PO), supplier’s invoice and a goods received note (GRN), which is a document confirming the receipt of goods or services, validating that what was ordered has indeed been delivered.

3-way matching ensures that the payment is made only for goods or services that have been both ordered and received, as evidenced by the alignment of the PO, invoice, and GRN. By requiring a match across all three documents, this process reduces the risk of paying for undelivered goods, overcharges, and fraudulent billing. This method is good for larger businesses or those with more complex transactions, where there is a higher risk of discrepancies.

The primary challenge in 3-way matching is the additional time and resources needed to review and reconcile three documents instead of two. But the increased control and accuracy often outweigh these costs.

DOKKA offers a fully automated 2-way and 3-way matching feature that seamlessly matches between invoices, POs and GRs – even in their source format (whether it’s a PDF or an image).

You can learn more about this feature here.

4-way matching

4-way matching is the most comprehensive form of invoice matching, typically used in industries where quality control is paramount. This process involves an additional step on top of 3-way matching and goes beyond confirming that the right quantity of goods was delivered at the agreed price. It also ensures that the delivered goods meet the required quality standards.

Industries such as pharmaceuticals, manufacturing, and food services, where quality is as crucial as quantity, find 4-way matching essential. By incorporating a quality check, 4-way matching helps mitigate risks associated with non-compliance, substandard goods, and contractual penalties.
4-way matching can be resource-intensive and time-consuming, as it requires thorough documentation and review processes. However, for businesses where quality is critical, the benefits significantly outweigh the costs.

In conclusion, the level of financial risk a business is willing to accept determines the type of invoice matching used. More comprehensive methods, like 3-way and 4-way matching, provide greater control and oversight, reducing the risk of fraud, payment errors, and non-compliance with contracts. While simpler methods like 2-way matching are less time-consuming, they might not be as effective in detecting errors or discrepancies. More complex methods, although potentially more labor-intensive, can offer greater accuracy and efficiency in the long run, especially when combined with automated systems.

The availability and adoption of technology also play a crucial role. Companies with access to advanced automated invoice matching systems may be more inclined to use complex matching processes due to the reduced labor and error rates associated with automation.

Why You Should Automate Your Invoice Matching Process

Many companies are increasingly adopting automation tools and software to simplify and accelerate the invoice matching process. These tools utilize optical character recognition (OCR) technology, machine learning, and artificial intelligence to automatically align invoices with purchase orders and receipts.

Automation streamlines the entire procurement process, from the initial purchase request to the final payment. It eliminates manual data entry and expedites approval processes, leading to quicker transaction processing and enhanced accuracy.

In addition to efficiency improvements, automation also offers greater insight into spending patterns and supplier performance. This enhanced visibility enables more informed procurement decisions. With detailed analytics, companies can identify cost-saving opportunities, negotiate better deals with suppliers, and pinpoint potential areas for process optimization.

Furthermore, automation plays a key role in mitigating fraud risks by flagging suspicious invoices or transactions, thus reducing the chances of human error or intentional malpractice.

While implementing automation in invoice matching requires an initial investment, the long-term benefits of increased efficiency and accuracy can lead to significant cost savings.

To discover how AP automation software can revolutionize your invoice matching process and mitigate the risk of fraudulent payments, book a free demo of DOKKA.

Invoice Matching FAQ

Do all businesses need to perform invoice matching?

Yes, accurate invoice matching is essential for any business that wants to maintain accurate financial records and avoid overpaying suppliers.

How often should invoice matching be performed?

It is recommended to match invoices as soon as they are received. Regularly scheduled invoice matching, such as weekly or monthly, also helps ensure timely payments and accurate financial records.

What happens if an invoice does not match with supporting documents?

In case of discrepancies, the company’s finance team will investigate the issue and resolve it with the supplier. This may involve requesting a credit note, adjusting the invoice amount, or discussing any other necessary actions.

Can invoice matching be done manually?

Yes, but manual invoice matching is time-consuming and prone to errors. Automation tools are now widely available and can significantly improve efficiency and accuracy in the invoice matching process.

What are the best practices for effective invoice matching?

  • Standardization of Procedures: Establish clear and standardized procedures for invoice processing. This includes setting guidelines for how invoices are received, reviewed, and approved.
  • Regular Training and Updates: Provide regular training for staff involved in the invoice matching process. Keeping them updated on new technologies, policies, and fraud prevention tactics is crucial.
  • Utilizing Technology: Leverage automated invoice matching tools to minimize human errors and increase efficiency. Advanced software can handle complex matching processes and provide valuable analytics.
  • Maintaining Accurate Vendor Data: Keep vendor information up-to-date to ensure that invoices are matched against the correct purchase orders and goods received notes.
  • Timely Reconciliation: Regularly reconcile invoices with purchase orders and receipts to catch discrepancies early and resolve them quickly.
  • Quality Control Measures: Implement quality control measures, especially in 4-way matching, to ensure that goods and services meet the specified standards.

Share this post